How to choose an online accountant
Ask for a named, qualified accountant, check their professional body and anti-money-laundering registration, and get a fixed fee in writing that lists what is included. Treat guaranteed savings and vague scope as red flags.
Choosing an accountant is mostly a question of asking the right things before you sign. This checklist works for any firm, online or local.
How to choose in five steps
- Decide what you need. Write down the work: year-end accounts, director payroll, VAT, bookkeeping, your own tax return, and any planning.
- Pick the type of firm. Use the comparison of provider types below to choose between high-street, online, app-based and sole practitioner.
- Shortlist three firms and ask each one the ten questions.
- Check their answers against public registers (see how to check the claims).
- Compare written quotes like for like using the quote comparison checklist, then read the engagement letter before you sign.
Ten questions to ask before you sign
- Who will be my accountant? A named, qualified person, not a queue.
- Which professional body are you a member of? CIPFA, ACCA, ICAEW or similar. The title accountant is unprotected, so ask.
- Are you registered with an anti-money-laundering supervisor? Firms providing accountancy services must be.
- Do you hold professional indemnity insurance? It protects you if something goes wrong.
- Is the fee fixed, and what does it include? Get it in writing, including calls, emails, payroll, VAT and personal tax returns.
- What will you do during the year? Ask about salary and dividend planning, deadline reminders and year-end reviews.
- How quickly do you reply? Ask for a typical response time, and whether it is a commitment.
- Which software do you use? It should work with your bank and bookkeeping.
- How do you handle HMRC and Companies House? You should be able to see what has been filed on your behalf.
- What happens if I leave? A good firm hands over your records without fuss, and notice terms should be clear. Ours are 60 days.
Red flags
- A price that seems far below the market, with scope left vague.
- No named person, and no way to speak to someone.
- Pressure to sign immediately.
- Guaranteed tax savings. No honest accountant can promise a figure before seeing your records.
- Reluctance to tell you their qualifications or registration.
Check the claims
You can check most answers yourself in a few minutes:
- Qualifications: search the member directory of the professional body the accountant names, such as ICAEW, ACCA or CIPFA. If you can't find them, ask for their membership number.
- Anti-money-laundering supervision: firms are supervised either by their professional body or by HMRC. For HMRC-supervised firms, use GOV.UK's check if a business is registered for money laundering supervision.
- The firm itself: look the company up on the Companies House register. Check that its accounts and confirmation statements are filed on time. A firm that is late with its own filings is a warning sign.
- Reviews: treat them as one input, and look for named, verifiable ones.
Online, local or app-based: which type suits you?
No type of firm is best for everyone. This is how the main options usually compare, so you can shortlist the right kind before comparing names.
| Type of provider | Usually suits | Watch out for |
|---|---|---|
| High-street practice | Businesses that want face-to-face meetings and a local office | Hourly billing, slower replies at busy times, extra charges for calls |
| Online fixed-fee firm | Directors who work in cloud software and want a set monthly cost and quick answers | Check you get a named accountant, not a rotating team |
| App or software-bundled service | Very simple companies happy to do most of the work themselves | Limited advice, tight scope, add-on fees for anything unusual |
| Sole practitioner | Owners who value one personal contact | Cover for holidays and illness, capacity at year end |
Whatever the type, the ten questions above apply. The title "accountant" is not protected, so the answers matter more than the label.
If an online fixed-fee firm sounds right, see how our online accountant service works and what it includes.
Quote comparison checklist
Ask each firm to fill in the same list, then compare like with like. A cheaper quote that leaves out payroll or your own tax return often costs more by the end of the year.
| Check | Quote A | Quote B | Quote C |
|---|---|---|---|
| Monthly or annual fee, fixed in writing | |||
| Year-end accounts and CT600 | |||
| Confirmation statement | |||
| Director payroll | |||
| Director Self Assessment | |||
| VAT returns | |||
| Bookkeeping | |||
| Calls and emails included | |||
| Named, qualified accountant | |||
| Professional body and AML supervisor | |||
| Typical reply time | |||
| Notice period to leave |
How we answer these questions
Claritax wrote this guide, so here are our own answers to hold us to. Ask every other firm on your shortlist for theirs.
| Question | Claritax's answer |
|---|---|
| Who will be my accountant? | A named accountant. The firm is led by Tanvir Alam, who is CIPFA qualified. |
| Professional body and registration | Claritax Accountants Ltd (company number 13000707) is registered with CIPFA and HMRC. |
| Is the fee fixed? | Yes. Plans start at £95 a month, calls and emails included. See pricing for what each plan covers. |
| How quickly do you reply? | Same working day, by phone or email. |
| Which software? | Xero, QuickBooks or FreeAgent. |
| What happens if I leave? | 60 days' written notice. We help with the move and release your records to you or your new adviser once outstanding fees are paid (see our terms). |
When we are not the right fit
We would rather tell you up front. Claritax works remotely, so if you want regular in-person meetings, a local practice will suit you better. We also focus on limited companies, directors and property companies, so a complex group with audit requirements, or a business needing specialist sector work such as charity or pension scheme accounts, should look for a firm that specialises in that.
Compare fees properly
Put the quotes side by side on scope, not price alone. Our guide to limited company accountant costs explains what is typically included, and fixed fee vs hourly explains why billing method matters.
Part of our online accounting hub. If you are leaving a firm, see switching accountants.
Frequently asked questions
How do I check an accountant is qualified?
Ask which professional body they belong to, then check the body's public register. Also ask who supervises them for anti-money-laundering purposes.
Should I choose the cheapest accountant?
Compare scope first. A low fee that excludes calls, payroll or tax planning can cost more overall. See our cost guide.
How long does it take to switch accountant?
Usually around two weeks. Your new accountant requests clearance from your old one, then arranges authorisation with HMRC and Companies House.
Do I need to tell my old accountant I am leaving?
Your new accountant normally handles this by requesting professional clearance, but you should confirm the leaving date and notice terms.
More questions? Browse the full FAQ
Written by Tanvir Alam, CIPFA. Reviewed 04/11/2026. This is general information, not advice. Rates and thresholds change each tax year, so check the current figures before you act.
Ready to ask us those questions?
Book a free call. We will answer every one on the checklist and give you a fixed written quote.