Companies House penalty appeal:
grounds and process
You can appeal a Companies House late filing penalty, but only on narrow grounds. GOV.UK says you must show that circumstances beyond your control stopped you filing on time, such as a fire destroying records a few days before the deadline. If the first appeal fails, there are two further stages. Being busy, short of money or let down by your accountant is unlikely to work. GOV.UK sets no fixed deadline for this appeal, but send it as soon as you can.
An automatic penalty for filing company accounts late can feel unfair, particularly when the delay was not really your fault. Appeals are possible, but Companies House does not cancel penalties because they are inconvenient. This guide sets out what GOV.UK says counts, what does not, and how to build an appeal that has a realistic chance.
Which penalty are you appealing?
Companies House has two separate regimes, and they have different rules. Check which one your letter refers to before doing anything.
- Automatic late filing penalty. Charged when annual accounts reach Companies House after the deadline. The amount rises the later they are. This is what most directors mean by a "Companies House penalty", and it is what this guide covers.
- Financial penalty for an offence. Companies House can also impose penalties under section 1132A of the Companies Act 2006. These follow a warning notice and have their own short windows for representations and appeals, in the region of 28 days. If your letter is a warning notice or penalty notice rather than a late filing penalty, read it carefully and act on its dates.
HMRC penalties are different again. HMRC can cancel a penalty where you had a reasonable excuse, and that process is separate from Companies House. See our self assessment penalties guide for the HMRC side.
What counts as grounds for appeal
GOV.UK's guidance says an appeal must give a specific reason for filing late, include details such as dates and times, and show that the circumstances were beyond your control. In practice that usually means:
- An unexpected event close to the filing deadline. GOV.UK's example is a fire destroying records a few days before the deadline. Serious illness or a death can also qualify. The event needs to explain why the accounts could not be filed on time, so timing matters.
- A Companies House error. For example, the filing was submitted on time but was not processed, or the deadline recorded was wrong.
Each case is judged on its facts, so a strong, well-documented appeal is better than a long one.
What GOV.UK says is unlikely to succeed
These reasons are listed as unlikely to succeed:
- The company was dormant.
- You cannot afford to pay the penalty.
- You relied on your accountant or another adviser to file.
- These were the company's first accounts.
- Another director was responsible for filing.
- You did not know when or how to file.
- The accounts were delayed or lost in the post.
- The directors live or were travelling overseas.
- The company is a charity or a flat management company.
It follows that being busy, not knowing the deadline or having poor records are not strong grounds either. If your real reason is one of these, do not expect the penalty to be waived on that reason alone. An appeal is still worth making if there was also a genuine unexpected event.
How to build a strong appeal
- Write down the timeline. List the filing deadline, the unexpected event with exact dates, and when you filed or plan to file. A reviewer should see at once how the event stopped you filing on time.
- Gather dated evidence. A doctor's or hospital letter, a death certificate or funeral notice, or screenshots of a failed submission. Evidence shows what happened and when.
- Show you acted promptly. Explain what you did once you were able to, and that the accounts are now filed or being filed.
- Keep it factual and short. Say what happened, why it stopped you filing, and what you ask for. Leave out complaints about the system or the amount.
- Send it complete, with everything in it. A strong first appeal is your best chance. If it fails, you can ask independent adjudicators to review it, then make a final application to the Registrar, but stages cannot be skipped. Use the appeal route set out on GOV.UK, and keep a copy of what you send.
File the accounts as well. An appeal is about the penalty, not the filing duty. While accounts stay unfiled, the penalty band keeps rising and the risk of compulsory strike-off grows. Use the late filing penalty calculator to see what each extra month costs.
Is there a deadline to appeal?
For an automatic late filing penalty, GOV.UK gives no fixed time limit. Even so, the longer you wait the harder it is to show that the event caused the delay, and the more the penalty and any collection action can grow. Appeal as soon as you can. If your letter instead gives a date for representations, such as under a warning notice, treat that date as binding.
If the appeal fails
- Pay the penalty. Unpaid penalties can be pursued by Companies House, including through the courts.
- Stop it getting worse. File any outstanding accounts and confirmation statements, and keep every deadline from here. A second late year in a row doubles the penalty.
- Protect the company. Continued non-filing can lead to compulsory strike-off, so deal with the filings first and the penalty second if you have to choose.
How Claritax can help
We catch up overdue accounts, review each penalty to see whether an appeal has a realistic chance, and prepare the evidence if it does. We will tell you plainly if it does not. See our late accounts rescue service, with catch-up work from £350, or book a free call.
Related guides
First Gazette notice guide
What strike-off means and how to stop it.
Limited company accounts guide
What to file and when it is due.
Late filing penalty calculator
See what the delay has cost.
Late accounts rescue
We catch up overdue filings for you.
Related reading: Accountant not responding? What to do next.
Frequently asked questions
Can I appeal a Companies House late filing penalty?
Yes, but only on limited grounds. You must show that circumstances beyond your control caused the late filing, with dates and details. GOV.UK's example is a fire destroying records a few days before the deadline. There are three stages: the Late Filing Penalties Department, then independent adjudicators, then a final application to the Registrar. Companies House does not collect the penalty while an appeal is being considered.
Is there a deadline to appeal a late accounts penalty?
GOV.UK gives no fixed time limit for appealing an automatic late filing penalty, but you should appeal as soon as you can. Do not confuse this with the 28-day windows that apply to a different type of Companies House financial penalty.
Will Companies House cancel the penalty because my accountant filed late?
Unlikely. GOV.UK lists relying on your accountant, being unable to afford the penalty, having a dormant company and filing first accounts as grounds that are unlikely to succeed. Directors are responsible for filing on time.
Do I still have to file the accounts if I appeal?
Yes. An appeal is about the penalty, not the filing duty. The accounts are still overdue, and the longer they stay unfiled the higher the penalty band and the risk of compulsory strike-off, so file them as well as appealing.
What happens if I do not pay a Companies House penalty?
Companies House can pursue unpaid penalties, including through the courts, and continued non-filing can lead to the company being struck off the register. Appealing does not remove the need to deal with the debt if the appeal fails.
More questions? Browse the full FAQ
Part of our Companies House problems hub: late accounts, penalties and strike-off.
Written by Tanvir Alam, CIPFA. Reviewed 03/11/2026. This is general information, not advice. Appeal rules are set by Companies House and can change, so check GOV.UK and your penalty letter before you act.
Penalty letter from Companies House?
Book a free call. We will tell you whether an appeal is realistic and what needs filing, with catch-up work from £350.